John Brown: Martyr or Madman?

Posted on December 2nd, 2009 by Paul Bernish

December 2 is International Day for the Abolition of Slavery.  It’s also marks the 150th anniversary of the execution of one of history’s most complex characters: John Brown, who was — to say the least — an extreme abolitionist.

john-brown-blog

Brown is most remembered for his abortive attempt to take control of the federal arsenal at Harper’s Ferry, Virginia in 1857.  His hope was to launch a civil war that would forcefully abolish slavery in the United States.  His mission failed, and in one of history’s ironic twists, Brown’s insurrection was put down by none other than Robert E. Lee, then serving with distinction in the U.S. Army.  Brown was wounded, arrested, tried and convicted of treason, and hanged in Virginia in 1859.  A little less than two years later, America became embroiled in a cataclysmic civil war that lasted four years and took the lives of more than 600,000 combatants, and one President.

Brown has since become a controversial figure, revered by many as a moral prophet who was willing to sacrifice even his life to rid the nation of slavery.  Others — with equal amounts of fervor — express great loathing for Brown as a madman and murderer who took the law into his own hands and used brutal violence as his call to action.  Biographies of Brown, of which there are many, reflect a wide range of opinion about the man, his life, and his ultimate impact on history.

On the anniversary of his hanging, an historian of Brown, David Reynolds, is now suggesting that the Obama Administration grant him posthumous clemency for his Harper’s Ferry insurrection.  What do you think? Should the President absolve a man who murdered five pro-slavery settlers in Kansas, and led an attack on the federal government?  Is John Brown a martyr to the cause of abolition and moral certitude?

Hard to say, but 150 years later, John Brown’s memory continues to confound and beguile.

Help spread freedom
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Tags: , , , , ,


 
2 Responses
Dan -

He was a fanatic who was martyred.

Betty Fitzgerald -

Indeed a fanatic, not secure in his pro abolition president’s ability to lawfully get the job done. In time, your organization may well redeem John Brown’s failed attempt. Your recent commercial showing white women as mothers who foster racism in their children was a hateful tactic to say the least and quite possibly more injurious towards equality, and a very subtle yet clear example of reverse racism. Hatred is a despicable trait that will always exist in the human race and I fear will continue and even be encouraged when it is publicly depicted as an inherently white race problem. Your arsenal of guilt producing commercials may well indeed be more powerful than the act of one John Brown against his government. I hope the end is worth the means.

Post Your Comment -*All fields marked with an asterisk are required.
  • Archives

  • Recent Comments

  • Elizabeth Guevara: Are you related to the Williams of Maryland Thomas 1693-1749 Prince George’s County MD
  • Mona Romans: Looking for my ggrandfather’s parents. His name was Alfred Jackson Reed and he was born in Indiana...
  • Earlie Hendeson: It absolutely was quite helpful. thanks for posting. I’ll share it with my friends. Many thanks
  • Monica Willams: How exciting for the Freedom Center! Certainly something the entire city of Cincinnati should be...
  • RUSSELL D. ESKEN: I’M LOOKING FOR INFORMATION ON LEVIN SCOTT BORN ABOUT 1790 AND LIVED ON THE EASTERN SHORE. I...

Join our Newsletter